DBL Law

DBL Law, Cincinnati Law Firm

SUBSCRIBE
  • About Us
  • Practices
  • Attorneys
  • News/Events
    • COVID-19 Business Resources
    • Blogs
      • Civil Litigation
      • Criminal Defense
    • Events
    • Firm News
    • Legal Alerts
    • Newsletters
  • Contact
    • Northern Kentucky
    • Louisville, KY
    • Cincinnati, OH
    • Careers
  • Excel Title

Plaintiff’s Attempt to Reserve Claims against Non-settling Dram Shop Defendant Felled by Circuity of Action

April 21, 2015 David Kramer

In Butt v. Independence Venture Club, Ltd., 453 S.W.3d 189 (Ky.  App. 2014), the Kentucky Court of Appeals held that the plaintiff’s entry into a settlement agreement including a hold harmless provision with a drunk driver and his insurance carrier precluded maintenance of a dram shop liability claim against the owner of a bar where the driver had consumed alcoholic beverages. The Court held under those circumstances that the dram shop claim, if successful, would create circuity of litigation, since the dram shop would have a right of indemnity from the driver, who would have a claim back against the plaintiff under the hold harmless. The decision was consistent with the prior Kentucky Supreme Court holding in DeStock #14 v. Logsdon, 993 S.W.2d 952 (Ky. 1999).

The decision highlights a pitfall for the plaintiff of attempting to settle a claim with one tortfeasor while attempting to reserve claims against others who have a right of indemnity against the settling party.

David Kramer is a Partner with Dressman Benzinger LaVelle psc with offices in Cincinnati, OH, Crestview Hills, KY and Louisville, KY

« Back to news

Subscribe
 
  • Best Places To Work NKY 2020
  • Best Places To Work 2020
  • Top Work Places

    2011 – 2020

NORTHERN KENTUCKY
  (859) 341-1881
CINCINNATI, OH
  (513) 241-4110
LOUISVILLE, KY
  (502) 572-2500
©Copyright 2021 DBL Law All Rights Reserved
THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT